Total Pageviews

Showing posts with label Marc Epstein. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Marc Epstein. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 13, 2012

Putting New York's School Reform in Perspective, by Marc Epstein

Here's another gem from the Ronin Teacher, Marc Epstein.  This one was originally published in the Huffington Post.


In case you haven't noticed, hunting public school teachers is currently the sport of choice for a passel of politicians, education philanthropists, and members of the Fourth Estate, from Maine to Hawaii.

You have the sense that if wildlife preservationists don't step in soon, the teacher may go the way of the Dodo bird.

For those of you who don't live in New York, it's likely that you haven't heard the cacophony of sounds emanating from the mayor's office, the teacher's union, and the news media, following the release of teacher rankings based on students' performance on state English and mathematics examinations for grades 4-8 spanning the years 2007-2010. 

The teacher's union unsuccessfully argued that the test results were wildly inaccurate, and releasing them could serve no useful purpose, and do much harm. Reputable testing experts confirmed those claims. The courts did not agree.

Mayor Bloomberg claimed he hadn't acted in bad faith by going back on an agreement not to release the data. The courts made him do it. 

The press demanded the results in their Freedom of Information filings, claiming the "public's right to know" transcended other considerations. Transparency was the watchword of the day.

The margin of error on the tests was as much as 53% on the English examinations and up to 35% on the math exams. Basic data collection on the numbers of children tested, class enrollment, and gender distribution were inaccurate when teachers compared the published data with their class lists.

The state admitted that the tests were poorly structured measurements of student achievement, and lacked validity. But the editorialists maintained that it was the right step in the right direction, and all things considered, should be published. Once they were published, they declared them "beyond valuable" and "beyond essential."

Perhaps sensing that Pandora's Box was about to open, Bill Gates wrote an op-ed in the New York Times, just three days before the results were made public. Gates, arguably the single most influential advocate of the movement to grade teachers with "value added" assessments, cautioned against shaming teachers lest the results be used punitively rather than as a corrective tool for improving inadequate teachers.

Throwing caution to the wind, the tabloids immediately began publishing names and pictures of the "worst" teachers in the system, at the same time claiming that the publication of the scores was designed to help these teachers improve! They must not have read Bill Gates' column.

A horse runs away from its barn. 
The blowback that followed the data dump prompted Merryl Tisch, the chancellor of the State Board of Regents, to suggest that a change in the state law might be advisable to protect the names of the teachers from public view, while still utilizing the test scores to evaluate their performance. But this may be a case of closing the barn door after the horse is out. For his part, the mayor has already indicated that he would oppose any change to the law.

Now that the "furies" have been let loose, I thought it might be useful if we stepped back and viewed this contretemps through a different lens, and place education reform in New York in its proper perspective.

For the first 50 years of the 20th century much was accomplished in New York City. Schools, subways, bridges, tunnels, airports, highways, and skyscrapers, transformed the landscape. The numbers are staggering. It included over six hundred new schools, six major bridges, and four tunnels connecting New York to New Jersey and Manhattan to the outer boroughs of the city.

When completed, the Freedom Tower at Ground Zero will have taken over thirteen years to plan and build since 9/11. The Empire State Building took less than two years. The 2nd Avenue subway, first begun in the 1970s won't complete its 8.5-mile construction until somewhere around 2050. It took less time to build over 600 miles of track and tunnels in the first fifty years of the 20th century. 

The Education Mayor soaks up some
wisdom from a noted scholar. 
When it comes to education the differences are palpable too. Instead of building schools, the "education mayor" takes pride in closing over one hundred and twenty five schools over the past decade, with promises of more to come before he leaves office in 2013.

Three hundred small schools have been located in closed comprehensive high schools, many of them landmarks almost a century old. If you work in one of those building you are reminded of what they once were, and the hollowed out shells they've become. You sense what Rome must have been like during its inexorable decline.

Despite claims of great success, remediation rates at the city colleges belie the validity of the increased graduation rates. In addition, about two hundred charters have opened under Bloomberg's tenure.

All things considered, you'd have to say that a sclerotic city has replaced what was once the nation's most vibrant metropolis, despite massive increases in public spending.

When you place education reform in this mix, a very different picture emerges. It isn't the great civil rights issue of the century. To call it that is an affront to those who fought, sacrificed, and even died to overturn racial segregation. It isn't the failed performance of the city's teachers that has led us this state of affairs. It is little more than the failure of publicly elected leaders to hire capable employees to carry out rational public policies.

Teachers didn't decree that students who make no academic progress can remain in school until the age of 21. Nor did they abolish the rigorous testing and hiring practices that existed under the defunct Board of Examiners and substitute a meaningless state teacher licensing examination process.

They didn't set policy that allows felons to go from jail to school and back to jail on a revolving door basis without establishing special programs that attempt to address soaring underclass crime rates. Teachers didn't make it all but impossible to expel a student. Teachers didn't foolishly destroy differentiated diplomas because to offer non-college bound programs to minority students was likened to racial profiling. Teachers didn't rip shop classes out of buildings. Teachers didn't dumb down the tests in order to inflate graduation rates. Neither did they invent phony "credit recovery" programs that allow students who hardly ever attended a class get credit for it by completing meaningless projects.

Large bureaucracies, which is what an urban school system is, among other things, are like an amoeba in the hands of the people in charge. Push it left, it moves left; push it right, it moves right. Split the amoeba in half and you'll have two amoebas. That is precisely what the school system has become, a socially engineered amoeba that has been pushed, pulled, and divided for decades.

The feigned outrage of politicians and reformers at the teachers, who have had their responsibilities increased over the past five decades, while their authority and legitimacy have been eroded in an inverse proportion, is nothing more than a macabre exercise in political nihilism. 

This treacherous assault on a vital public institution is little more than what Joseph Conrad described as, "Personal impulses disguised as creeds." I predict it will come back to haunt its perpetrators.

"... We but teach bloody instructions, which being taught return to plague the inventor." -- Macbeth by William Shakespeare.

Picture credits:
     
     http://www.tapirback.com/tapirgal/gifts/friends/extinct-animals/dodo-bird-plastic-f1353.jpg   
     https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiDUO_qj7ILt3XfJlUU9Kv2mbVPdORy6FS4Oh6gEWgrEuYr8qMyxL6lE6gps3fK8UfnhA6Oa317sG9bFaia0ibREXm5DPzwMK2-s_sfG0ECR5CmRTxO1LhUJJ4rUKwff4MmNdg5jLygn8HL/s320/LeftTheBarn.JPG    
     http://assets.nybooks.com/media/img/blogimages/Black-Bloomberg_jpg_470x2367_q85.jpg

Sunday, October 9, 2011

The Tenure Trap, by Marc Epstein

Marc Epstein, the Ronin Teacher, had this article published by Huffington Post over a year ago.  Little has changed since then, except that the Chancellor is now Dennis Walcott rather than Cathie Black--which is also not much of a change.


Chancellors Cathie Black and Dennis Walcott stand behind Mayor
Bloomberg.  Always.  Unquestioningly. 

When there is evidence of bad public policy, you can safely assume that it took two parties working collaboratively to create the swamp.



New York's Department of Education and the teachers' union have found themselves mired down in a dispute over the fates of more than a thousand teachers, many of whom have no assigned teaching position, but continue to collect full-time salaries.

This group of teachers is collectively referred to as ATR's, or the Absent Teacher Reserve. Large numbers of ATR's are not instructing students in their licensed areas. Instead they often find themselves working as substitute teachers. 

At various times these teachers have been labeled incompetent or too lazy to seek positions by Joel Klein. He wants to fire them.

To judge from his statements and newspaper editorials, we are simply facing a case of old time union featherbedding.

If the problem isn't resolved over the next few weeks, Cathie Black will inherit this mess, and all her public statements to date indicate that she has bought Joel Klein's narrative, hook, line, and sinker. 

The primary reason that so many teachers are out of a job stems from Klein's policy of closing comprehensive high schools, declaring them "failed" enterprises, and replacing them with small high schools.

Since the closing is a "hostile" takeover the teachers too are "failed" and sent packing, rather than placed in the new small schools.

If you are in the wrong place at the wrong time, you can lose your position with either a short time served in the system or with 20 plus years on the job.

When you impose this method of staffing on the largest school system in the country, something has got to give. In fact, it's only logical that a number of teachers would find themselves inhabiting the limbo world of the "ATR."

This limbo world can find a music teacher covering classes for absent social studies teachers, while his music program is assigned to a social studies teacher. I know because this precisely what occurred in my school.

The sooner the myths about public school staffing are dispensed with, the better the public interest will be served, because this is Joel Klein's self-created crisis.

Tenure: tenure for public school teachers is not a lifetime sinecure. In most respects it is no different from civil service protections for police, fire, and sanitation workers. You have to have due process in order to fire an employee.

We should recall that the civil service laws first instituted on the Federal level were the direct result of a presidential assassination in 1881, when a disgruntled officer seeker shot President Garfield.

Back in 1883 the cities of New York and Brooklyn served as the model for civil service reform nationwide on the local level.

The New York City schools once had a rigorous accreditation process for teachers. It included a meaningful written examination of the subject area and an oral exam. The Board of Examiners wrote and administered the tests.

As standards ebbed, the once vaunted Board of Examiners was whittled down until it was quietly put out of business in 1990.

The once demanding exam was replaced by a ludicrously easy interview and a more questionable statewide written exam.

It's no accident that the dumbing down of the hiring requirements coincided with the dumbing down of state testing for our children too. 

Mayoral control gave Michael Bloomberg the power to re-establish a Board of Examiners with the stroke of a pen, but nothing has been done to return rigorous standards to the hiring process.

Perhaps Bloomberg, who didn't grow up in New York, is unaware that a Board of Examiners ever existed? After all, it's far easier to run a PR campaign than it is to institute real reform.

The union, never one to miss an opportunity, has yet to call for a return to the hiring standards under the Board of Examiners that helped make New York's schools the finest in the country.Why should an experienced teacher have a tough time landing a new position you might ask? Well, along with the downsizing of schools came Klein's decision to budget schools according to the actual salaries of their teachers.

Before mayoral control, a high school teacher counted as a "unit," which meant whether you had a school with lots of experienced teachers or mostly rookies, the cost for staffing the school was the same. The teacher "unit" would represent the average price of compensating one of the 80,000 teachers in the system.

If a school closed, or its population declined, teachers who were no longer needed there were placed in available slots without having them go into the so-called "open" hiring market.

By forcing the principals to figure the real salary of each teacher into their budgets, they have every incentive to hire younger lower salaried teachers and to avoid the more experienced ones, who were too expensive. In Klein's universe inexperience and lower salaries becomes a virtue, while experience be damned!

Would critics of tenure suggest that if a firehouse is closed because of a reorganization move by the department, the firemen are responsible for finding a new job within the system? Would these critics claim that young inexperienced firefighters are preferable to experienced ones?

With the press providing the wind for his sails, and Bill Gates funding the school voyage, Klein's assault on teachers and comprehensive high schools proved irresistible for someone with no real administrative skills. Ask yourself which role is easier, playing Tom Silva on This Old House, or just taking a wrecking ball to the whole place?

Around now, you might be asking yourself why the teachers union acquiesced to the ATR? To say that the union has taken a pounding in the press and from the chancellor over the past seven years is an understatement.

In typical New York fashion, the union stood by when a good policy, the School Based Option Staffing and Transfer Plan was being strangled, and agreed to the ATR pool.

The SBO had a cooperative team of teachers and administrators select new faculty members collegially. If someone with loads of seniority applied for a job and had nothing else going for them except time in the system, they could be rejected.

The SBO was already in place and had been spreading throughout the system when Bloomberg took over the schools. So Klein's claim that he was being strangled by union seniority rules was simply a myth.

If the union was as omnipotent as the editorialists claim, why didn't it block, or wage a PR campaign against this new fatally flawed hiring process and fight for the SBO?

Yet the public discourse is diminished by the union's failure to make its case for the rank and file teacher to the public. 

There's no way to divine the answer to that question. In all likelihood the UFT knows that no matter how much ink is spent reviling them, no arbitrator would overturn the civil service laws and allow unassigned teachers who otherwise have satisfactory performance records to be fired.

In the end, the DOE and the union have been clever by half. Hundreds of millions have been wasted. The hiring process hasn't been improved, and teachers who remain the vital component in the education process are further diminished.

If this self-inflicted "crisis" were given to a business management class as a case study, it's likely that they would conclude that the negotiators on both sides of the table were idiots.

Photo credit: http://cdn2-b.examiner.com/sites/default/files/styles/large/hash/d0/09/4_439.jpg

Thursday, October 6, 2011

The School Closing Follies, by Marc Epstein

Marc Epstein, also known as the Ronin Teacher, sent us this article about school closings. We all know that school closings harm teachers by forcing them into the Absent Teacher Reserve (ATR).  Here, Epstein explains why closing schools is of no benefit to students, either.  


Fran Tarkenton running away from a defender.  He also should
 have run away from the temptation to comment on
education,

About 15 years ago I clipped out a cartoon from a newspaper that depicted a public school administrator explaining the latest school reform craze to his colleagues. He was holding up two models of schoolhouses. One was a large building and the other a one-room schoolhouse.


The caption read, "first we take the small school and put it in the big school. Then we take the big school and..." The sentence was left incomplete, but I'm sure you've figured out the punch line.

The days of re-configuring buildings, open classrooms, building interiors without walls, and portfolio assessments, belong to the Jurassic period of education reform.

They are well gone. At the start of each school year we expected a new catch phrase or slogan about learning and teaching to be thrown at us from the administrators on high. We listened, we complained, we yawned, and we went about our business of trying to educate our students. And yet, as disruptive and fruitless as these schemes turned out to be, I find myself recalling those days with feelings that border on the nostalgic.

We've now moved into an era in which politicians, philanthropists, and a school of education reformers now believes the only way to education salvation is to literally close schools and fire teachers.

The fervor of this movement evokes the reformist's zeal that has from time to time swept this country, ostensibly with the best of intentions, and almost always with unforeseen consequences that prove a detriment to our society. This time around Carrie Nation has given way to Michelle Rhee. Given the current fevered pitch that accompanies the rhetoric of "reform," I have the sense that if the schoolhouses were still made of wood, Bill and Melinda Gates would be funding torches.

In the past two weeks the current Chancellor of the New York City Schools, Dennis Walcott, delivered his first major policy speech, in which he declared that after 10 years of mayoral control and $100 billion dollars of increased education funding, the Department of Education has concluded that middle school students are entering high school in large numbers unprepared to do high school level work!

Just last week, Walcott's deputies announced that part of the solution to the problem would be to spread the misery by closing more elementary and middle schools. Madame Defarge, who now resides at the New York City Department of Education, has just knitted 20 more names of schools slated for the guillotine. They are slated to follow the almost 100 that have had their fates sealed.

A discussion with a group of the sub-species known as the classroom teacher would have elicited a number of truths that might have resulted in some meaningful changes in the running of our urban schools. It also would have saved the taxpayers their hard-earned tax dollars along with massive infusions of foundation funds that have had limited results at best.

The sooner these unpleasant truths are articulated far and wide, the better our schools and country will be for it. For those of you who do teach, I'm not telling you anything new.

Truth #1 If a student enters high school in my state (New York) with a 1 or 2 reading level out of a possible 4, they are functionally illiterate and won't receive a high school diploma unless the standards are either dumbed down or their grades are fabricated. A double period of English each day won't make a difference.

Truth #2 Allowing someone other than a special needs student to remain in a regular four-year high school until the age of 21 ensures that large numbers of "students" will make no progress because they believe that failure has no consequences. Many students sit on the fence. If they inhabit a world where there are no consequences for non-performance then large numbers of them wind up making minimal progress. A school system that offers endless chances because it believes it is benevolent, winds up being cruel in its own way.

There's summer school, night school, phony credit recovery, transcript manipulation, designed to inflate graduation rates. The students feel as if they are walking on a high wire with an endless series of nets under them. They have no fear of falling off. They are encouraged to live out an infantilized existence by a system that is supposed to be teaching them how to live life's lessons as an adult.

Truth #3 Teachers and administrators have the responsibility of overseeing the welfare of their students, but have no authority to keep miscreants out of the schoolhouse. There are no special schools or programs for students who have been incarcerated. They are dropped into a regular school as soon as they are released from jail with no regard for their future or the safety of others.

Truth #4 About 25 percent of the students in our high schools don't want to be there or take the courses that are required of them. The folly of making these students "college ready" has come at the expense of eliminating school shops, commercial diplomas, and vocational training.

Restore differentiated diplomas. Provide programs and schools for students that have made absolutely no progress after two years of high school, and watch how quickly our urban schools are turned around.

Truth #5 If the editorial board members of the major New York newspapers had to cover 5 classes in a New York City high school, they'd never make it to lunch! That's because they have no knowledge of how the schools are run or the actual working conditions. They've decided that the true path to success resides in the private marketplace.

They reify this view by running editorials and op-ed pieces written by non-educators who claim to be experts on education. If you read their resumes, they are usually business management experts or statisticians.

If I were to submit an op-ed to the Wall Street Journal, it wouldn't make it past their spam filter. But Fran Tarkenton offers a loopy view of why the schools should be run like the NFL, and it's prominently displayed.

Somebody at the Journal should have told Fran that the teachers aren't the players who "can't be fired." We are the coaches who are expected to turn everyone who walks through our classroom door into a star in a game where nobody is allowed to lose.

Try running an NFL team where every walk-on is expected to play and excel and see how long the league survives.

When these issues are addressed, we can begin to earnestly evaluate teacher performance.

Photo credit:
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEjnDFmIu7cRLPs5SSNKia5mWqazv3VKgAIwVGcXz516Fjd74lVYPrYrta9YbOXDjpjSwzw5bcRc5eBdjC-FOE_rYUas5FYnqTWSPftldj76_VuG-6c4O7BSoApfNGcKPMBo4Fcmg_uEy2M/s320/fran-tarkenton.jpg

Sunday, September 25, 2011

The Ronin Teacher predicts pusillanimous prevarications at UFT-ATR meetings

Marc Epstein, otherwise known as the Ronin Teacher, looked into his crystal ball and predicted what will happen at the meeting between the UFT and the ATR teachers next week.  We hope he's wrong.

A Japanese palmreader at work
The UFT will do everything in its power to convince the ATRs that they have their backs and that they won the LIFO War with Bloomberg.



Mulgrew - Casey- Mendel can't explain why: 



a) the hiring freeze was lifted in August just as the ATR pool was growing;
b) they agreed to allow ATRs to be moved from week to week--it's a mystery.

ATRs that have per-session jobs like coaching might find it impossible to do those jobs as they are shifted around a large borough like Queens and Brooklyn. 

The ATR agreement really handed Bloomberg a LIFO victory by calling it something else. As if the life of a Ronin weren't bad enough, they threw in the right to move them around weekly.

The UFT is complicit in these terror tactics, or they are remarkably stupid. Perhaps it's a combination of the two.

Picture credit: http://lukehalliwell.files.wordpress.com/2008/10/japanese_fortune_teller.jpg?w=300&h=224

Saturday, September 10, 2011

New York City Ronin Teacher, by Marc Epstein

The following was sent to NYCATR by Marc Epstein.  Mr. Epstein was a history teacher at Jamaica High School; he is now a member of the Absent Teacher Reserve (ATR), stationed at a "re-start" school in Richmond Hill.

Mr. Epstein's articles have been published in a wide variety of first-rate publications.  After reading this article you'll agree that Mr. Epstein has deserved to be published by the New York Sun, the  Washington Post, the Huffington Post, and now, by NYCATR.



http://www.episodeguide.us/episodeimages/ronin-warriors.jpg

About six weeks ago I received a letter informing me that I was now a member of the Absent Teacher Reserve pool of the New York City Department of Education. That meant that because my school was being phased out and wouldn't be accepting new students my services were no longer wanted. Approximately half of the remaining faculty at Jamaica High School received the same notice.



We've now joined the pool of approximately 2,000 "ronin" teachers who were instructed to find jobs by entering an "open market" that lists available teaching positions on the internet, and attend "job fairs."


The term "ronin" (literally, "floating men") originally described samurai in medieval Japan who for one reason or another no longer had a lord to serve, and, hence, lost their employment. It's estimated that around 1600, the number swelled to over 400,000. (Japan: An Illustrated Encyclopedia. Kodansha, p. 1275 vol. 2, ISBN 4-06-931098-3)

For those unfamiliar with Japanese history, the ronin genre of movies became famous worldwide in the 1950s and 60s. Arguably the most famous of which were The Seven Samurai and Yojimbo, directed by Akira Kurosawa.

I dutifully followed the instructions on the Department Of Education website and applied for jobs in my field. So did my colleagues. We didn't receive a single call for an interview.

I received an email informing me that a "job fair" was taking place at the Brooklyn Museum last week. Four Jamaica High School ronin piled into my car with our bar-coded invitations and traveled to the museum.

Faceless bureaucrats with name tags and Blackberries greeted us at the door. We were told to take the elevator up to a magnificent rotunda with desks arranged in a circle. School representatives were seated at the tables with signs indicating their school and positions available.

We ran into other ronin who had been dropped from our school the year before. They told us that all of the job fairs that they had attended had been a waste of time.

Our group consisted of two English and two Social Studies teachers. Although many positions were listed on the Internet during the "open market," there wasn't a single job interview in our field at the museum.

If you don't live in New York, you can read tales of Ronin-Teachers at a website devoted to chronicling their travails.  [NYCATR: I guess that's us.] Aside from acting as a samizdat for people in our predicament, it reveals the dirty little secret that New York City really has no public left in the political sense anymore. That's because in another era an earsplitting roar would have erupted over the deliberate misuse and abuse of qualified public servants.



I felt like I was an extra in Chushingura, a Japanese play about the forty-seven samurai who took revenge after the forced suicide of their lord Asano Nagamori. Asano had drawn his sword in the Shogun's castle after being humiliated by the chief of protocol. Forty-seven of his samurai who had become ronin after Asano's death, waited two years to exact vengeance. (Japan: An Illustrated Encyclopedia. Kodansha, p. 404 vol. 1, ISBN 4-06-931098-3)



They found employment by taking on all sorts of demeaning occupations until they were sure that the secret police were no longer watching them, then they carried out their vendetta.


When I was doing my graduate work in Japan, I observed that the story would be performed annually. 

Every Japanese person knows the story. It's been presented in Bunraku puppet theatre, Kabuki plays, movies, and television series, in countless revivals for the past three hundred years. Nevertheless, everyone remains riveted by the story and enjoys the play for the staging and the performance.

In the end the ronin get their revenge and assassinate the chief of protocol, but the Shogun, not knowing what to do with these loyal samurai, at last offers them the only honorable Japanese solution. They are allowed to commit seppuku (ritual suicide) en masse.

Feudal arrangements have displaced rational bureaucratic function. Increasingly, the twenty-first century business model for running the country's largest public school system resembles something out of a Japanese medieval play. 

Rather than the high-tech model that was supposed to usher in the new age of education innovation, we have an authoritarian regime bent on holding the teaching profession responsible for ten years of meaningless doctored test results. In addition to the human cost of a decade of poorly educated kids, the budget has doubled to $22 billion a year!

A kind of kabuki-charade plays out with a script that talks about "business models," "open markets," and "job fairs," while no honest method of staffing schools with qualified teachers who have become ronin is put in place.

With the start of the new school year the editorialists will once again rail about unemployable teachers who are living on the taxpayer's largesse, while the mayor revives his campaign to terminate us.

Our union leaders celebrate when Mayor Bloomberg's phony threat to lay off thousands of teachers isn't realized. But when the Department of Education lifted the hiring freeze this summer so that schools can hire cheaper inexperienced teachers at precisely the same time that the ronin teacher pool is being stocked with older experienced bodies, nobody says a word. That includes the union and New York's vaunted press. 

At the end of the day the teacher-ronin are expendable. After all, when you go to the movies and buy popcorn, does it matter who puts the popcorn in the box, or if there is a new person behind the counter every three weeks?

The MBA types who now run our schools will tell you that if you can manage a muffler shop you can manage a McDonald's, a bowling alley, or a movie theatre, so why not a school? In this corporate universe teacher experience is as irrelevant as is the size of the classes.

But in our society ritual suicide is not an honorable solution. So I don't expect a mass suicide of ronin-teachers even if the mayor offers it as an option.

All of the teacher-ronin have received email notification to report to various schools the day after Labor Day. We can be utilized in any capacity, and have no idea if we will be teaching in our subject area.

The Department of Education reminds me of the "man on the street" who was asked by a reporter whether he thought it was worse to be ignorant or indifferent? He replied, "I don't know and I don't care."

The pity is Kurosawa is no longer around to make a movie about the New York City ronin-teachers that would give Davis Guggenheim's Waiting for Superman a run for its money.